On to the Humdinger.
American Idol top three elimination
The top three are singing “Ain’t No Stopping Us Now,” and again I ask, really? All the songs in the musical ‘verse to choose from, and we get that cheeseball song?
Crappy Ford commercial. “Heaven.” This week they didn’t even try, did they?
56 million votes last night. I didn’t bother, because I can never get through on anyone’s line if I call after 9 p.m. here. So if David Cook doesn’t make the final, you can blame me. I take full responsibility.
We’re recapping, we’re recapping, and now it’s my favorite moment from last night. The Archtweener of Cluelessbury singing about my boobs. Awesome. Now if that had happened on the same night that Paula judged Jason’s second song before he sang it, I might still be hyperventilating.
Um. Fantasia’s on stage right now, singing a song called “Bore Me,” and amen to that. No, back it up, I take that back. This very well may be the most craptaculasmic performance ever on that stage. I can’t believe I voted for her. Seriously, I had to pause it and take a break, because I couldn’t take it. Hey look, Sabrina Bryan in the audience. ROFL, the look on Simon’s face. He can’t believe he voted for her either, apparently.
Ryan wants to know if he can start the drama now. He brings out David Archuleta, who takes solace in the knowledge that if he goes home tonight, he’ll still have the very important task of carrying the Ring to Mordor to save Middle Earth. We get to watch the Archtweener’s trip home to Utah. Oh, and I’m so happy because we get to listen to him sing “Imagine” while we watch the clip. Hooray.
Now we get to watch the Archtweener’s going home video, since we won’t get to see it next week. But the awesome thing about it is we don’t have to hear Ruben Studdard sing; instead we get the uber-talented Graham Colton. I love him (even have his CD from 2003 or 2004 back when he was playing bars in Dallas, before the name change to Graham Colton Band and the second name change to Graham Colton).
Syesha went back to Florida. Awww. Her dad’s still clean. That’s awesome. She’s crying even more than Archy cried on his trip home. Kids these days.
Ryan asks Syesha if Pauler’s comments last night were harsh. Simon says they were a little over the top. Syesha’s going home video, set to “I Believe.”
David Cook’s turn. David, why so sad? Why so detached? Why so subdued, word nerd? Huh. It wasn’t David’s idea to audition; he was there in Omaha to provide moral support for his brother. Producer came up with a camera, David said, no, I’m not auditioning, he is. Producer said now you are, and so now, if David wins, his brother gets half of everything. His brother did the whole hometown tour with him, and David went to visit his elementary school music teacher.
I like his going home video. Feel a little bad for his brother, though.
Simon says if it’s the final he’s hoping for, it’ll be a real humdinger next week. Pauler and Randy are up in arms over the use of the word humdinger, because apparently it’s way too sophisticated for them to have ever heard of it.
David Archuleta is in the final. David Cook is, too! Yay for David Cook! I think David Cook with either one would be a good finale, but a finale without David Cook wouldn’t have been worth watching. Help us, David Cook, you’re our only hope for a good finale.
Anyway, Syesha sings herself out, and next week David Cook puts the beatdown on the Archtweener.
More American Idol.
7 Snarkbacks to “On to the Humdinger.
American Idol top three elimination”
Snarkback!
You must be logged in to post a comment.



May 15th, 2008 at 12:49 am
During the Fantasia performance, Simon had a “What in the bloody hell is this?” look on his face. It was hilarious and made the whole thing worthwhile.
May 15th, 2008 at 3:58 am
I predict that the one to win American Idol will be named David….hahahahaha!
And WOW to Fantasia. Not good WOW either. Just WOW. The bright red hair, the weird flying dance, and screaming. It was very bad. Worse, even, than David’s boo. Sheesh.
May 15th, 2008 at 9:08 am
I am glad we have these 2 different types of singers that have made it to the finals. I am rooting for David A, but will not be upset if David C wins either. Both are good for 2 different reasons. As far a Fantasia??? I think she was absolutely Fantastic!!! I realized I was actually smiling during the whole peformance, and was actually moving my feet around a bit…couldn’t help it…that girl knows how to work it out!! LOVED LOVED LOVED her performance.
May 15th, 2008 at 9:09 am
This is my first year to watch AI and, since my radio station is tuned to 60s oldies, am hardly up on the current music, I had no idea who Fantasia is. However, my husband pointed out that I had exactly the same expression on my face as Simon while watching Fantasia’s performance. Is she/he a female inpersonator?
May 15th, 2008 at 11:14 am
Did Fantasia even sing? And, I’m in agreement with Simon - just by watching his face.
Also, I had the feeling that Syesha knew she was going home. No huge emotion shown there at the end.
David Cook better win, or I’m not watching any more. (I think I say this every year though!)
May 15th, 2008 at 3:15 pm
I just got this bad feeling the twerp already has this in the bag.
May 18th, 2008 at 12:09 am
I definitely agree with Jessica… I think David has it locked up!
I regret that I have to miss it this year (I don’t have a DVR) but my wife keeps me up to date. And your recaps are incredibly amusing!
Keep it up!!!